The checklist
- The surface feels like sandpaper. Etched finish snags swimsuits and scrapes knees and toes.
- Stains come back after treatment. Metal, organic and mineral stains that return after acid washing are inside the finish.
- You can see gray patches. Thin spots where the shell is showing through.
- The finish is flaking or sounds hollow. Delamination means the finish is separating from the shell.
- Calcium nodules or crusty bumps are forming where water is getting into the shell.
- Cracks you can see or feel, especially in steps, benches and the floor.
- Chemicals disappear fast and the water won't stay balanced, because a porous finish keeps changing the chemistry.
- Water loss you can't explain, which can come from cracks or failed fittings.
What isn't a reason to resurface
Light surface stains that lift with a stain treatment, minor color variation in a newer quartz or pebble finish, or algae from a chemistry lapse usually don't need a resurface. A good contractor will tell you if cleaning or an acid wash will do.
What to do next
If you're checking three or more boxes, get a written estimate. Our cost guide shows what to expect, and the process guide explains the job from drain to start-up.
Frequently asked questions
Can an acid wash fix a rough pool?
An acid wash removes a thin layer and some stains, but it also thins the finish. On an old, rough finish it usually buys little time.
Are cracks always structural?
No. Many are surface checks in the finish. Others go into the shell. A contractor can tell the difference once the pool is drained.